Are Walleye Good to Eat and What does Walleye Taste Like?

Last updated on April 19th, 2023

Leonard Friedrich

Are walleye good to eat? Many fishermen have pondered whether walleye are good to eat. Consuming fish can be a delightful experience as well as nutritious; yet, it is critical to recognize which sorts of fish are secure for eating. Walleyes are considered some of the tastiest freshwater gamefish around – but how do you prepare them and what does walleye taste like? Let’s take a closer look at this popular species so we can answer the age-old question: Are walleye good eating?

Best Walleye Rods Review: Are Walleye Good to Eat?
Are Walleye Good to Eat? Yes, they have a superb and mild flesh

Table of Contents:

What Does Walleye Taste Like?

Walleye is a freshwater fish with a mild flavor and delicate texture. Its flavor is sweet and nutty, making it a desirable choice for many dishes. When prepared correctly, walleye has an exquisitely delicate texture that melts in the mouth. The buttery richness of walleye, along with its inherent sweetness, gives the fish a mild but enjoyable flavor that can be complemented by appropriate accompaniments. There are also subtle undertones of grassiness and earthiness that come through when cooking this fish properly. The overall flavor is mild but still quite enjoyable when paired with the right ingredients or sauces.

The key to preparing walleye correctly is understanding its unique texture. This type of fish has an incredibly soft consistency that requires gentle handling while cooking so as not to break apart too easily or dry out quickly during preparation processes such as grilling or baking. To ensure optimal results, try lightly coating fillets in oil before cooking them over medium-high heat on a well-oiled pan or grill grate until they reach an internal temperature of 145°F (63°C).

Not only does walleye have great taste but it also offers some impressive health benefits too. Walleye is rich in omega-3 fatty acids which can help reduce inflammation and may improve heart health by decreasing cholesterol levels and triglycerides within the walls of blood vessels. Additionally, walleye provides plenty of essential vitamins like B12 which helps support energy production within cells as well as promote healthy red blood cell formation within our bodies’ systems for better overall wellbeing.

Safety should be the top priority when consuming raw walleye; uncooked seafood can pose a health risk if not properly handled. Sushi grade varieties are generally safe for consumption without additional preparation, however other types may require extra precautions such as marinating overnight in an acidulated water mixture or freezing them at -4°F (-20°C) for seven days prior to slicing into ceviche recipes. To ensure safety, take heed of these key steps and enjoy your meal with peace of mind.

Is walleye good to eat- Filleting a walleye
Are Walleye good to eat? Fileting a walleye – always make sure to keep the fish fresh and cooled before preparing it

Can You Eat Walleye Raw?

Can you eat walleye raw? Yes, it is possible to eat walleye raw – but caution must be taken. Raw walleye is safe to consume as long as it has been properly handled and stored. Sushi-grade walleye should be purchased from a reputable fishmonger or seafood market that can guarantee its freshness and safety. If purchasing frozen, make sure the package has not expired and was kept at the proper temperature throughout its journey from lake to plate.

When preparing raw walleye, start by filleting the fish with a sharp knife, removing all bones and skin. Next, slice into thin strips for sashimi or small cubes for ceviche recipes. Ceviche recipes typically include citrus juices such as lime or lemon juice which act as an acid bath to “cook” the fish without heat while adding flavor and texture – think of this dish like a tartar sauce without mayonnaise. Other ways to enjoy raw walleye include sushi rolls with pickled ginger and soy sauce or simply served over steamed rice with seaweed salad on top.

Raw walleye, rich in omega-3 fatty acids to reduce inflammation, vitamins A and D, lean protein, minerals like phosphorus and selenium plus its low fat content compared to other types of seafood make it an ideal choice for health-conscious individuals. This makes it a great pick for those seeking nutritious meal choices with plenty of vitamins and minerals.

Key Takeaway: Walleye is a delicious fish that can be enjoyed raw, with the right preparation and safety measures. Cooking walleye opens up even more possibilities for enjoying this popular freshwater fish; let’s explore some of these recipes next.

What do Walleye taste like? Freshly prepared walleye filets
What do Walleye taste like? Freshly prepared walleye filets

Recipes for Cooking Walleye

Grilled Walleye with Lemon Butter Sauce

Grilling is a great way to enjoy walleye and bring out its subtle flavor. Preheat the grill to a medium-high heat for this tasty dish. Rub the fish fillets with olive oil, season them lightly with salt and pepper, then place them on the hot grill grates. Grill for about four minutes per side until cooked through. Meanwhile, melt butter in a small saucepan over low heat and add fresh lemon juice, garlic powder, parsley flakes and paprika. Simmer for five minutes or so until everything is blended together nicely. Serve the grilled walleye topped with the lemon butter sauce – it’s an easy yet flavorful meal that any angler would love.

Baked Walleye with Herbs and Garlic

This simple yet tasty recipe makes use of some common pantry staples like herbs de Provence mix (or dried thyme) as well as garlic powder to give it plenty of flavor without much effort at all. Preheat the oven to 375°F (190°C) before arranging the walleye fillets in a greased baking dish. Grease a baking dish generously with cooking spray or olive oil then arrange the walleye fillets in it skin side down. Sprinkle liberally with herbs de Provence mix (or dried thyme), garlic powder and salt & pepper; drizzle over some melted butter if desired before baking for 20-25 minutes or until cooked through depending on thickness of fillet pieces used. Enjoy this savory baked walleye warm from the oven.

Heat up some vegetable oil in a skillet over medium-high heat before adding your seasoned walleye fillets, one by one. Fry each side for about four minutes until golden brown and then remove from the pan with tongs to avoid splattering hot fat. Accompany the golden brown walleye fillets with a homemade tartar sauce of mayonnaise, pickles/gherkins, capers, mustard and other seasonings to tantalize your taste buds.

Preheat the broiler setting on your oven to a high temperature, then brush both sides of the seasoned fish fillets lightly but evenly using vegetable oil before placing them onto a greased broiler rack directly below the heating element inside the oven. Leave them undisturbed while they cook under intense heat for approximately five minutes per side depending upon their size and thickness. Keep an eye out so as not to overcook them, or else they will become dry and tough instead of soft and flaky. Once done, remove from the oven and serve immediately alongside freshly prepared mango salsa mentioned earlier… Enjoy responsibly friends.

Are Walleye Good to Eat and what does walleye taste like: Grilled walleye filet with vegetables
What does walleye taste like? It has a buttery, mild flavor

Key Takeaway: Walleye is a great option for grilling, baking or frying. All methods require seasoning the fillets before cooking and can be served with complementary sides such as lemon butter sauce, herbs de Provence mix (or dried thyme), garlic powder, tartar sauce or mango salsa to take it up a notch.

Where Do Walleyes Live?

Walleyes, a freshwater fish found in North America and Europe with an especially large presence in the Great Lakes region of the United States, inhabit deep water habitats such as rivers, lakes, reservoirs and ponds. Walleye populations vary depending on environmental conditions.

Habitat and Distribution:

Walleyes prefer clear water with plenty of vegetation for cover. They can be found in depths ranging from 10 to 40 feet or more during spawning season when they move into shallower waters to lay their eggs. Walleyes are found in other regions, such as Canada and Alaska, as well as the northern states of Minnesota, Wisconsin, Michigan, New York, Pennsylvania, Ohio and Iowa.

You can employ various methods to land walleye, such as trolling crankbaits or spinners near shorelines and weed beds; jigging lures that mimic baitfish; casting spoons or jerk baits around structures like rocks; bottom bouncing live bait rigs; still fishing using natural baits under a bobber rig; fly fishing streamers near weed beds during spawning season and vertical jigging over deeper areas where schools congregate year-round.

The best time to go walleye fishing is during late spring through early summer when they’re spawning near shorelines. Look out for surface disturbances caused by their feeding activity at dusk or dawn as a telltale sign that they’re around. Cold fronts are also prime times for walleys since oxygen levels drop and fish gather together looking for food sources concentrated near bottom structures like sunken logs.

Walleye in their natural habitat

FAQs in Relation to Are Walleye Good to Eat

Is a walleye a good fish to eat?

Yes, walleye is a great fish to eat. It has a mild flavor and firm texture that makes it popular among anglers. The white flesh of the walleye is lean and flaky when cooked properly, making it an excellent choice for those looking for healthy options in their meals. The Omega-3 fatty acids present in walleyes offer numerous health benefits, furthering its appeal. With its delicate taste and nutritional value, there’s no doubt why this fish remains so popular among fishermen everywhere.

What’s so special about walleye?

Walleye are one of the most sought-after fish species in North America due to their delicious taste and fighting spirit. They can be found in both fresh and saltwater, with many anglers targeting them specifically for their size and quality of meat. Walleye have a unique ability to see well in low light conditions, making them ideal targets when fishing during dawn or dusk. Their diet consists mainly of smaller fish, insects, crustaceans, larvae, mollusks and other aquatic organisms; they’re also known as “yellow pike” because of their yellowish coloration on top with white underneath. With proper care taken while catching walleye – such as using barbless hooks – these fish will continue to thrive for years to come.

Is walleye high in mercury?

Walleye is not considered to be high in mercury. The EPA has set a safe level of 0.3ppm for mercury in edible fish tissue, and walleye usually falls beneath this limit. It is therefore advisable to research local water contamination levels prior to consuming any fish from a particular area.

How often can you eat walleye?

Walleye can be eaten up to twice a week. It is essential to bear in mind that walleye are an oily fish, so eating them excessively should be avoided for a nutritious diet. Eating more than two servings per week may lead to health issues such as high cholesterol and increased risk of heart disease. When consuming walleye, it is best to cook them lightly with low-fat cooking methods like baking or grilling. This will help reduce the amount of fat and calories in each serving while still providing the essential nutrients found in this delicious fish.


Walleye make for a fantastic meal, and the response to “are walleye edible?” is an unequivocal affirmative. Walleyes have an excellent flavor that can be enjoyed raw or cooked in many different recipes. The best part about eating walleye is that they live all over North America so you won’t have trouble finding them. With this knowledge, we hope you feel confident cooking up your own delicious dish of walleye today.

If you’re looking for the best advice on fishing tackle, lures, techniques and more to help you catch walleye that are delicious to eat – then look no further! Our comprehensive guide will give you all the information needed to become a successful recreational angler.

Scroll to Top